Skip to content

Vegan diets are not tied to birth defects

March 3, 2009

Yesterday, The Vancouver Sun published an article with a headline declaring “Vegan diets tied to birth defects”, and this got my blood boiling enough to send a letter to the Sun’s Editor, as well as the Canada & World section editor Massey Padgham. You can read the Canwest News Services article here (The Vancouver Sun webpage for the article was not opened up to comments), as well as on The Province’s webpage.

Here is what I wrote:

Re: “Vegan diets tied to birth defects”, 2nd March, 2009

This article does contain some truths, in that a deficiency in one’s diet can lead to birth defects during pregnancy. However, as published in The Vancouver Sun with the headline stating vegan diets are to blame is irresponsible.

Any person can have a B12 deficiency, even someone eating a diet based on meat and dairy products. B12 is a bacterium that is found naturally in soil, but intensive farming practices in the last few decades have depleted soils worldwide to the point that naturally occurring B12 in soil is no longer a reliable source.

B12 occurs in meat and dairy due to bacteria that forms during the processing of meat in slaughterhouses and in dairy and eggs in processing facilities. B12 is sometimes also fed to factory farmed animals if they don’t acquire it directly or indirectly from B12 bacterium from plant sources; it does not occur in meat or dairy products naturally.

As the article states, regardless of their diet all women of childbearing age should be supplementing with B12, not just vegans and vegetarians. Clearly, it’s incorrect to state that a vegan diets leads to a birth defect that could and does happen to anyone regardless of their dietary practices.

While my letter didn’t get published in the paper, here is the response I got this afternoon from Massey Padgham:

Agree. Headline writer honed in on one group that story merely suggested was “at risk”.

This article may have passed under the radar of many readers were it not for the headline used with the printed version of the article, the headline used for the online version of the article did not pinpoint vegean diets. My concern with the print publication was that, once again, misinformation about vegan diets would be spread via irresponsible feamongering by Canwest’s editors.

6 Comments leave one →
  1. March 3, 2009 3:21 pm

    my blood boiled as well when i read it (and left a message about “tripe” on their comments, ha). in reading the rest of the comments though, it made feel good that all of them stated the errors in the article. so that at least is good. i just hope their average reader see’s past their “editorial/opinion”.

    and for the record all vegans i know are FAR more knowledgeable about diet/nutrition than carnivores, and get their levels tested regularly.

  2. March 3, 2009 7:01 pm

    Well put! You did a great job outlining exactly what was wrong with the article.

    One of our friends is a vegan mom and her comment may get published. I know a bunch of vegan moms and they all have completely healthy children.

  3. March 10, 2009 11:39 am

    Thanks for writing this. I have been fuming about this since I first read it online–there are a number of sites reporting this story and it is so frustrating. I appreciate your response so much.

  4. April 19, 2009 12:57 pm

    I’m glad you responded. Why the attack on vegans, time and time again?
    A girlfriend of mine who was sick(throwing up)the whole time she was pregnant, hardly gained any weight and her baby was fine. I’m sure she didn’t get all of her nutrients. I need to stop because I feel the boil in me coming on. ughhhhh.
    A friend of ours a couple of years ago, a “meat and potatoes” man who hardly eats anything else, asked if I took supplements. My husband just stared at me waiting for my response. Can you believe that? He’s the one who should be taking supplements. He eats no fruit, except strawberries no vegetables, oh I take that back, corn and potatoes and his salad consists of lettuce, cheese & croutons loaded with thousand island dressing!!! okay i’m done.

  5. Monica Glasscock permalink
    August 25, 2009 7:04 pm

    I was very intrigued by your information about B12 and I was hoping you could send me a link (or several) so that I can become more informed on the topic. Please and Thank-You!

  6. Agnes permalink
    September 5, 2011 1:35 pm

    B12 is not a bacterium!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: